Teeling Single Pot Still
Originally published 07/01/2019
By now I'm sure you are familiar enough with me to know that although being the token Irish writer on the Malt Team that I am no cheerleader for the Irish Whiskey industry. My own personal whisky collection roughly favours Scotch over Irish two to one in number. I'm essentially here because Jason and Mark can't be bothered buying Irish whiskey and Adam's too busy exploring England's new model army of upstart distilleries between cider tastings.
But the Irish whiskey industry doesn't need me to be a cheerleader for them. In fact it doesn't require any of us who write about whisky to be a cheerleader for them. That's why they have the Irish Whiskey Association. That's why they employ Brand Ambassadors. That's why they pay PR and Marketing specialists. They are the ones who tell the stories, embellish the history and sell us the 'Brand'.
No, I am here, not to publicise and kiss bum cheeks. I am here to run a critical eye over proceedings and tell you my honest opinion. It's why Malt exists and why so many of you return to read our collective material on a daily basis and to consistently interact with us. It's why I feel humbled and privileged to even write here in the first place.
Adam recently posted on Twitter musing over why in many industries including wine, literature, film and so on that criticism is an accepted part of life, yet the whisky industry recoils in horror at the merest indication of nay-saying.
My own take on this is that the whisky industry as a whole rarely receives totally honest feedback. Whether in printed format or digital there is a reluctance to really say what you think. If you do those precious samples might just stop rolling in! And of course, if you do utter an opinion that goes against the collective grain you may well be seen as the wild-eyed crackpot of the community.
The days of having to rely on industry freebies are well and truly over though. There is no need to sugarcoat opinion in fear of being blacklisted by brands. In Ireland we have a great community of bloggers and enthusiasts now and if you so desire you can spend every evening of your weekend from Friday to Sunday sharing in a bit of whisky-related banter and craic on Twitter. They are also generous souls, with samples of all sorts crisscrossing Ireland at an alarming rate.
It's this burgeoning community that shares, not only in Ireland, but all over the globe that means industry reliance and back scratching should be a thing of the past. It should also allow unfettered opinion giving.
There is nothing wrong with accepting freebies and samples from the industry – I've done it myself here on Malt, but that shouldn't and doesn't mean that I will go easy on them if the whisky isn't great... in my opinion. I think reviews such as Prizefight and Hyde to name a couple show that free whisky is no guarantee of a kind word.
Today's review is made possible because of that sharing ethic. My sample of the newly released Teeling Single Pot Still came from fellow enthusiast Jamie better know as @whiskey_jac on Twitter and Instagram. The mad eejit cracked open a bottle of this new release and actually shared it. Imagine that!
This new release from Teeling caused quite the stir here in Ireland. The Teeling Distillery was the first newly built distillery to operate in nearly 125 years when it opened it 2015 and marked the return of working pot stills to Dublin nearly 40 years after the closure of the old Powers John's Lane Distillery in the mid-1970's. Exciting times indeed.
So the release of the first 100 bottles of this Pot Still in September 2018 was a historic moment for Dublin whiskey production. Of course, this also meant that there was enormous interest generated around the whiskey and all eyes were on Teeling to see what the launch price would be. After all, we are getting used to seeing ludicrous prices for young whiskey these days, and young whiskey this is. Teeling first started distilling in March 2015 so this stuff was little over 3 years old.
To be fair to Teeling they came up with a novel plan. The first 100 bottles would be sold at auction with all profits going to local Dublin charities. You are all probably well aware that bottle no.1 sold for £10,000 breaking the world record for the most expensive bottle of whiskey sold from a new distillery. Crazy, but at least the charities did well out of it.
The first commercial release of the whiskey came with the launch of Batch 1 in its striking blue livery in October 2018 at, for me anyway, the surprisingly low price of €55 and limited to 6,000 bottles. Kudos to Teeling for selling it at a reasonable price. Such is the interest in new Irish releases they could easily have sold this for double the asking price and I doubt many would have batted an eyelid.
Comprised of a mash bill that is 50/50 malted and unmalted barley this whiskey has been matured in virgin oak, ex-bourbon and ex-wine casks. It's natural colour, non-chill filtered and bottled at 46%. All good so far.
Teeling Single Pot Still - review
On the nose: Noticeably soft and herbaceous. Lots of barley and biscuit. Linseed oil, lime zest and white grapes. Apple schnapps, a little lemon, vanilla and unripe banana. A touch of dry white wine. Waxy and slightly metallic – old pennies and brass. Predominantly new make-ish, draff and grist.
On the palate: Like the nose this is very soft on arrival. Melon, grape, unripe apricot and a lemon and lime tartness. Then damp cardboard and envelope glue mid palate before a gradual release of pepper and pot still spice. Again it all feels very new make spirit. The finish is very short, slightly metallic with lemon and grapefruit peel.
This is a release that many Irish whiskey fans have been fawning over but I'm going for the wild eyed crackpot viewpoint here... a position I'm more than comfortable with as the grumpy one of the Irish whiskey blogging world.
I can understand the enthusiasm to release this considering the lack of any whiskey being distilled in Dublin for so long but I just wish that Teeling had shown patience as this does not showcase what they are doing terribly favourably. It is just too young and under matured. Even the casks haven't been terribly interactive with the spirit.
Certainly not as accomplished as the Dingle First Release Pot Still and I found that to be wanting. I think that this should be an example to other start ups here in Ireland... bottle when it's ready, not before. Take a leaf from the Echlinville book. They have stock that is now 5 years old but are still showing no signs of releasing their own distilled whiskey, rather they intend to bottle when they feel it is ready which I think is very commendable indeed.
The Teeling Pot Still shows promise though. Once it gets to 10 years old or thereabouts I think we'll see a whiskey worth drinking. Unfortunately, this release has left me very underwhelmed.
Lead image from Teeling.
Comments from original post
Great review as always and very honest. I think the 3/10 is fair here, in the hype – I got a bottle myself, cracked it open and was left underwhelmed, spirit tasted very young and it’s not a patch on Teelings single Malt. They should have sat on it a few more years!
Thanks for reading the review and commenting. Interesting to see our experience with this one seem somewhat shared. I’m sure given time this will develop nicely but as is it’s not an experience that would have me reaching for the bottle in a hurry.
I think 5/10 would be fair. Releasing something at this age is more about allowing whiskey fans to see how the whiskey develops over the years. It’s a marketing opportunity too, of course.
It didn’t taste very pure pot still to me. But it was great to taste another position from outside Midleton.
I agree it is nice to see further development of pot still whiskey outside of the Midleton fold and while this is indeed a whiskey that will progress over forthcoming batches I’m going to stick to my score of 3…its just not that great and certainly fell short of the Dingle first release, which as I said in the piece, I found wanting also.
thanks for the read and comment!
I loved the blue on the label and it would have immediately caught my eye in the shop, but it does sound a bit young and slightly rough. Love the honest review.
The blue is indeed eye-catching, paying homage to the counties sporting colours. Really stands out on a shelf i must say. Hopefully the whiskey will standout for the right reasons in the future.
This party is NOT LIT! You pathetic, bum-cheek-kissing, jealous gobshite.
This party WAS LIT until you arrived. Party Pewper.
Great review on the nose with it. Always look forward to your reviews keep up.
Cheers lad, will keep on keeping on haha
Great honest review as always. After buying a few brand new releases, I’ve learned a lesson to wait for them to mature a bit before spending hard earned cash on newbies. The only exception I’ve found were Kilchoman (when they were considered new) and Cotswolds. Others…i’ll wait a decade before spending money on them
I must look into some of the Cotswolds stuff…I can let Adam have all the fun with the English whisky market.
But it certainly seems to be an issue with a lot of new distilleries…putting out very young whiskey that isn’t ready. At least Teeling didn’t go OTT with the pricing. It will be interesting to see how this develops over time.
It would appear from the outside that the Teeling family like money just a bit more than whiskey. As a former Harvard Business graduate John Teeling approached the whiskey industry in Ireland originally like an entrepreneur. There was a gap in the market etc etc. The fact that Cooley’s initial few years of distillation yielded some quality single cask single malts is most likely down to the craft of the then distiller David Hynes as well as quality sourced malt and casks. While these have been, in recent times the standout modern Irish Whiskies, most bottled by independents in Scotland and Germany, Cooley produced a LOT of average whiskey over its time.
It proved however to be a very successful and profitable business, enough to warrant Beam Suntory paying the Teelings $95m for the distillery and brands. That Harvard degree paid off then.
Since opening Teeling they have sold the ‘first Dublin distillery’ very hard. This doesnt really mean anything unless they are going to make an exceptional whiskey in hommage to the great producers of the past.
They however proceeded to bottle over 220 whiskies with the Teeling brand, obviously from old Cooley stock. Quality of these has been poor/average/ some good. For anything good the prices were immense and pretty much every whisky has some sort of wine finishing going on. What are they trying to hide? So the protection of their new brand around ‘quality’ doesn’t seem important to them, (as long as they are making $).
This 3 year is no surprise to us. Again, questionable oak and I wonder in the future will we see once again a LOT of average whiskey with the odd exceptional single cask, unfiltered from Cadenheads or The Whisky Agency.
The Teelings are, it would seem, very smart businessmen but unfortunately the modern Irish Whiskey landscape is full of smart businessmen, investors and speculators.
Many new distilleries are being sold as ‘craft’ and regional with the hopes of large investment, possibly to be sold to a corporation later on and its clear that many of these are producing run of the mill spirit. Dingle and Waterford however seem to be doing it right, thus far, time will tell. However, we hold little to no hope for anything exceptional to come out of Teeling and should it happen, you will be made to pay over the top for it.
An interesting and though provoking comment.
Jack Teeling has stated on IG that this is a developmental whiskey…that each subsequent batch will highlight its further development. Only time will tell and the developement might be easier to spot if there wasn’t a myriad of casks used in the maturation.
As regards the idea that many new distilleries are following the lead of John Teeling in hoping for a corporate buy out further down the line, well that could lead to many being sadly disappointed and out of pocket. Lets hope that these new distilleries are there for the love of producing great whiskey and not just parting punters from cash.