The Irish Review - Dunville's, Old Comber and Redbreast PX

Welcome to review number 101 and a look through some of the random bits and bobs from my own bottles or samples I have received from generous souls.

Dunville's 1808

Dunville's latest entry into the frankly 'bursting at the seams' blend market of Irish whiskey. This iteration is a blend of grain whiskey, two different malts of which one is peated and pot still whiskey. it's bottled at 40% and will set you back around £33 from the distillery shop. My sample came courtesy of the Belfast Whiskey Week Bonus Box.

Colour: Straw

Nose: Plenty of vanilla here alongside apple & pear. Some lemon wedges, caramel, a florists shop plus a biscuity note. Some loose black tea leaves and cask char.

Palate: For the abv a nice buttery mouthfeel. Runny honey, pear, vanilla, graham cracker, mild pepper leading to more lemon peel and a soft, soft wisp of smoke.

Finish: Short with lemon peel, gentle smoke and mild honey

Echlinville Old Comber

After a 70 year hiatus the good folk at Echlinville Distillery have resurrected the Old Comber brand with a blend of Pot Still whiskies (of which includes some of their own spirit) that have been aged in American Oak and Bourbon casks before being finished in Ruby Port Casks. Allegedly the spirit in roughly 6 years old and will in time be a 7 year old release, harking back to the original Old Comber 7 year old release, although I'm not sure if there are plans to have an age statement on the label at that point. It's bottled ay 46% and retails at £45 if you can get a bottle......this stuff sells out fast and I'm yet to be quick enough off the mark! Thanks to Dave Cummings for the sample and the photograph.

Colour: Amber

Nose: A very fragrant nose - fresh oak, woody spices in the form of cinnamon and nutmeg. Cola bottle sweets, vanilla pods, toffee and cocoa powder. Marzipan with hints of ground ginger and white pepper. Some beeswax too. Finally a little herbal note verging into fresh tobacco.

Palate: A nice oiliness to this. Sweet and spicy. Apple and pear tart tatin with butterscotch sauce. Cinnamon, nutmeg, pepper and ginger heat grip the side of the tongue before releasing into vanilla sponge cake with raspberry jam, milk chocolate buttons and juicy, fresh raspberry and strawberry.

Finish: Medium length with oak tannins, fresh ginger, pepper and caramel sweetness.

Belfast Whiskey Week Dunville's 12 year old PX Cask Strength Cask 1330

An exclusive release for the Belfast Whiskey Week 2021 festival of all things whiskey related. Bottled at 57.2% with an outturn of 310 bottles. Dunville's call this a finish but in reality it's a double maturation with the spirit having rested in the PX cask for between 2 to 3 years. On release this was £125 but making more at auction these days if you're interested in trying to acquire a bottle. Thanks again to Dave Cummings for the sample and the picture.

Colour: Copper

Nose: Sandalwood, sweet black coffee, treacle, nutmeg, dried tobacco, dates, plums, california raisins. Mild pepper with clove, orange zest and butter cream. A little furniture polish too. Grated dark chocolate. Water brings cherry menthol and stewed stone fruit.

Palate: At full strength I found this a little closed. Lots of brown sugar, raisins and sticky dates. Then a big, big spice kick of clove, peppermint and chilli. Water does open things up better now with stewed apples, orange peel, peach and espresso.

Finish: Just verging on medium with chilli heat and oak tannins lingering.

Redbreast PX Edition

A limited edition from Midleton that got all the Redbreast fans in a fluster and is now like hen's teeth in Ireland except, it seems, at The Loop Duty Free in Dublin airport which has loads of the stuff. Costing £72 a bottle and released as part of the Iberian series this follows the Lustau Edition formula of being matured in both bourbon and oloroso sherry casks being being transferred into PX hogsheads for at least a further 12 months maturation. Bottled at a healthy 46% abv. Thanks to Dave Cummings aka @the_mash_upper for the sample.

Colour: Russet gold

Nose: A heady mix of woody spice, dark fruit and sweetness. Spicy European Oak and pot still spice with sticky dates, raisins covered in dark chocolate, stem ginger, hazelnuts and fresh orange zest. Toffee, blackberries, nutmeg and roast coffee beans.

Palate: A syrupy texture with plenty of PX influence. Jammy berries and raisins, almonds, milk chocolate and orange peel. Dates again with nutmeg infused icing sugar. Some sweet cinnamon, ginger and vanilla cream. 

Finish: medium length with sticky PX, cocoa butter and some oak.


Let's kick things off with the DLD 5 year old. It's a fairly straight forward affair that has quite good balance between nose and palate but with a slightly limited flavour development. It's definitely a good session dram to share with mates alongside a pint of stout. That said I've worked my way through most of the bottle without much complaint, maybe that it's just a little pricey for what it is.

So Dunville's have again entered the blend market which I find interesting considering they already have Three Crown's and Three Crown's Peated so I'm not quite sure what the need is for the 1808. I mean it's alright but not particularly interesting enough to make me consider purchasing a bottle. In fact if you want a hint of peat the Three Crown's Peated does the job much more successfully. Looking outside the brand it would be hard to look past the Dark Silkie as a much more engaging alternative.

The Old Comber next. Honestly, I think Redbreast 12 year old has very real competition now at the price point, in fact I'd go so far to say I'd happily plump for the Old Comber over it. It's slightly younger but that doesn't come across in terms of mouthfeel, nose or palate at all. Really superb stuff from the lads at Echlinville and I can see why it never hangs about long on release.

The Belfast Whiskey Week Dunville's PX cask strength has an absolutely belter nose, really fantastic, one to nose for hours. Unfortunately the palate, especially at full strength, just didn't live up to it. At full strength I found the palate a little cask dominant and pretty spicy. A little water is definitely need to open things up and release some fruitiness from the Cooley distillate which restores some balance to proceedings.

The Redbreast PX Edition is easy to sum up - cask dominated. This is very much a dessert dram and one for all you out there with a sweet tooth. As ever the nose is a thing of beauty. Billy and Dave down at Midleton sure know how to concoct engaging noses with whiskey. But for me, especially as I don't have a particularly sweet tooth, it's the palate where this falls down. It's just too sweet. The use of smaller hogsheads over butts means the PX maturation has just taken over proceedings to the point that I can't help but think you'd be better just buying a bottle of PX instead.


Dunville's 1808 - 4 out of 10

Echlinville Old Comber - 8 out of 10

Belfast Whiskey Week Dunville's Single Cask - 7 out of 10

Redbreast PX Edition - 6 out of 10

If you’d like to support my humble site you can do so following the ‘buy me a coffee’ link. Thanks for reading.


Popular Posts